Having grown up a tomboy, I spent most of my childhood insisting that I was a feminist, but always attempting to ensure that I never became a "crazy feminist." Looking back, my early stabs at feminism could at times be easily misconstrued as a minor gender identity crisis. I gave up pink at the age of 6, and began wearing t-shirts, sports jerseys, soccer shorts, and sweatpants every day of my life. In kindergarten, we were supposed to line up in two different lines: the traditional Boys' line and Girls' line. Quite the young radical, I took it upon myself to stand in the boys' line whenever possible. I even made up a catchy little chant in which I would point over to the girls' line and say "girls' line" and then point back to the line I was standing in and say "boys' line." If I remember correctly, I had a dance to go along with this too. This was also the point in my life where I insisted upon wearing backwards baseball caps alllll the time. When I think about these years, I realize that I sincerely wanted to be a boy. When kids in my school would ask me if I wanted to be a boy, I wouldn't think twice about saying yes. Much to my parents' pleasure, this did end up proving to be a phase in my life. Seeing as how it was such an innocent age, I was very confident and comfortable with myself. I was an only child showered with attention from my parents, so it's safe to say that I probably loved myself as a child. I liked my body, and I never had a problem with the organs I had been supplied with (aside from a short phase as a toddler when I repeatedly tried to pee standing up since my dad got to). My desire to be a boy simply came from what I associated being a girl with. As a kid, I associated being a girl with being a sissy. When I was 5, I loved sports, and I loved winning. I didn't want to wear dresses because I didn't want to be treated as a girl. I wanted to be able to beat all the boys in sports, and most of all, I wanted to be taken seriously. Somehow, even at that point in time, I managed to pick up on how the concept of femininity often implied being submissive or weak.
So, through all of my childhood, I fought to prove that girls could do anything that boys could do, and even do it better a lot of the time. I had lots of female friends, but none of them seemed to share my passion for competing with boys, so most of my friends were actually boys, and it was completely beyond me to ever consider that boys like these could be the reason for an inequality in the sexes. Only the crazy, lesbian, bra-burning feminists didn't like men, and I would always like my best friends. However, fast-forward a decade, and I have reluctantly become the crazy, man-hating feminist that I always swore I'd never become. Don't get me wrong, most of my friends are still men, and as much as I wish this weren't the case, I'm still sexually attracted to them. It's been a steady process that followed the promise I wrote in my journal this summer to "stop letting men control my self-image." This was a goal I knew would be challenging, if not impossible. I'd noticed that I was constantly seeking this validation from men. I felt good about myself when they were interested in me, but horrendously unattractive when they weren't. This is completely normal phenomena for women everywhere, which is sad. As much as I don't like thinking about it, I can admit that one of the major forces in me trying to separate myself from the male sex was "kind of" dating someone who really fucked with my head. We'd been friends for probably about three years before we finally hooked up this summer, though I had been lusting after him almost since the beginning of our acquaintanceship. Shortly after our first encounter of this nature, I left the country for three weeks, and we kept in contact while I was away. While away, I had a countless amount of conversations with my friend who I'd traveled with about our endless dissatisfactions with men. Coincidentally, this friend is now seeing a girl for the first time in her life, and very happy about it. I came to the conclusion that, because I'd just gotten out of my only serious relationship and had not enjoyed playing the role of a girlfriend, I was fine with keeping things casual and noncommittal. After my return, this boy and I became commiserators of sorts who shared a mutual attraction. The fact that he was moving quite far away in a couple months was even more inspiration not to get attached. Needless to say, this was an interesting set-up. One I was fine with. Then, he began complicating things by asking me out to dinner or arranging to go see movies or something. Unable to deny my attraction to him, I became excited at the idea of going on what appeared to be dates (though, out of my own sensibility, I refused to label them as such... I would not be the clingy one). He would tell me what time to expect a call from him, and then I would sit around waiting for hours, and never receive one. He'd eventually contact me and always have a believable excuse as to why things didn't work out. Mind you, we did go see a couple of movies, which I was planning on paying for myself, but did not after his insistence upon being a gentleman. When he'd shit on our plans, I'd always resist calling him, so I could avoid becoming the needy girl who can't pick up hints. I'd usually call once, and then try to forget about it. Anyway, most of the time we spent together was spent watching movies, drinking, and talking. We had really similar tastes in movies, so it was a setup I enjoyed. I ended up loaning him some of my CD's and DVD's. Long story short, I saw him the night before he moved, and forgot to get my shit back. I've spent the past few months contacting him very occasionally, usually not more than once a month, to try to get all of my stuff back. He apologized profusely once for still having everything, and told me he'd mail them the very next day. This didn't happen. It's been over a month now since I've talked to him. I gather that he's back in the area now, and clearly avoiding me. Last week, I called him, knowing full well that I would be sent to voicemail, to try to both get onto cordial terms as well as to try once again to get $86 worth of my stuff back. I tried to convey that there were no hard feelings (despite this being inaccurate), and he has still not contacted me back. Anyway, I realize that none of this has to do with what I'm getting at and is really just me being pissed off at what a ridiculous, spineless puss-ass he's being... (not bitter)
Anyway, it was this particular person that, much to my dismay, probably did ignite a latent hostility toward the male sex. I looked at the type of person he was to try to figure out exactly what it was about him that had gotten me so hooked. It had started out as him being one of the only people I'd ever met who liked the same kind of music and movies as me. He was also the ever-tempting "older guy." I'm almost positive that the reason I was so attracted to him was because I viewed him as the embodiment of what I could not attain. When we first became friends, we bonded over both struggling with depression. I gave more weight to this similarity than to the endless amount of variables that made him a completely illogical match for me. We had completely different backgrounds (me - counterculture girl who loathed high school, him - tri-sport athlete who reveled in it), completely different beliefs (me- liberal atheist, him- conservative protestant), and completely different intended futures (me- get the fuck out of the midwest, go to a good school, and try to find what I'm good at, him- ?????). Upon analysis though, I realize that these were all the variables that made him seem unattainable to me, and made it a challenge to successfully seduce him.
When I look back on our little fling, I become infuriated at how he successfully turned me into the thing I swore I would avoid being. The clueless, clingy girl who can't take a hint. Though I personally know that I wasn't clingy, and merely seeking enough respect to at least be informed of when plans will not work out (plans that I never initiated), it pisses me off to no end to think that he probably views me as such. Though I'd never treated him as a boyfriend and never expected him to be a boyfriend, he somehow managed to make me out to look desperate and needy.
After this, I became even more determined to avoid being submissive in any relationship with a male. I began noticing a certain male-female dynamic between all of the couples I was around. The males were constantly belittling the females' ideas and treating them as if they were uneducated children. I can no longer tolerate the fucked up protector role that so many men assume in relationships. Even my male friends who claim to be proponents of gender equality cannot carry out these ideals toward their girlfriends. No matter how intelligent the female, her boyfriend becomes this twisted sort of father figure. This concept rings throughout our culture today. Women are "girls" for their entire lives, whereas "boys" reach a point where they become men. Our pornography is filled with women intentionally making themselves look younger by shaving their pubic hair or even pretending to be "barely legal" because this is what turns millions of men on. I got to hear a transsexual woman speak. She talked about how sexism is much more prevalent than people realize. Though she had the same resume as a woman that she did as a man, she was no longer taken as seriously during interviews, and could distinguish how differently she was being treated. After finally getting a job, her ideas were constantly dismissed until the same ideas were brought up by a male coworker. In today's society, gender equality is a myth. We've turned terrible double standards into acceptable parts of pop culture. Men are meant to seek out as many women to sleep with as possible, and the women are supposed to want a committed relationship and become unnecessarily attached to the men they sleep with. After all, women who have casual sex with multiple partners are sluts. Women continue to oppress themselves by referring to the women who act like men as sluts. In several of my classes this year, I have been the lone "feminist." In a sociology class, the instructor brought up the tradition of men always paying for dates. I spoke out against this tradition and insisted that this tradition aided the oppression of women by making them dependent on men. The tradition started when women weren't allowed to have jobs, and literally had no way of paying for themselves. Now, when we are able to get jobs, there is absolutely no reason that women should continue to expect men to pay for them. A girl brought up "chivalry" as a defense for this act. This is a common expectation that women have for men, and I view it as nothing but counterproductive to equality. Chivalry rides on the "damsel in distress" concept where women need simple tasks done for them, so as not to overexert their dainty nature. As long as men continue to have excuses to assume the role of the breadwinner or protector, women will continue to be pigeonholed into the role of homemaker or mother. In an economics class, I was the only female who stated that they would not be content with a traditional economy (men work, women stay at home as babymakers and caretakers). Two of the smartest girls I know who plan on pursuing medicine and engineering stated that they wanted to marry a rich husband, so they could just be stay-at-home moms who don't have to do anything.
I realize that this entry has gotten much lengthier than I'd intended it to, and if anyone actually reads it, since it is my first blog, I'll write a follow-up... But I'll leave with the question, even though women can now get jobs and Title 9 has been enacted, have we made any real progress?
Monday, January 21, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
14 comments:
Here, here, so true and a great post. Very honest and exactly what I believe happens in society. Only problem is I don't know how the hell to fix it. Cheers Jen.
I completely agree that the so-called concept of women finally being equal to men hasn't actually happened yet. Part of the trouble is that the major religions are pro-men and anti-women, so the majority of the world is by default pro-men.
Looking forward to reading more from you!
Hey, i know i'm only 18 but i have an oppinion about this... I was raised completely ignorant to this problem, and only a few years ago realised that there may be something here, at the point in my life when i started interacting with men and seeing how they treat me. I have a tendency to date older men, 20-somethings, and though all of them have agreed that i am intelligent, educated, and capable, few have managed not to treat me like a child. Frankly, thismakes me angry.
And it makes me ALL THE MORE angry because there is nothing i can do about it except stoop to their level and play domination games in order to receive some respect.
I really liked your post, sincerely, because i can relate to what you said. It just makes me very angry because there's not much i know we can do about it.
I agree with what you're saying, and I think it's wrong. I'd just like to share a bit about me.
I grew up in a house of just women. Me, my mother and my nana. As a child I mainly had male friends and we did a lot things together. Mostly they'd do what I thought would be fun (like play pokemon games or chasing). I was pretty tom boyish, but only realise this now since I'm very girly. I'm just myself, I do what I like. I dress whatever way I want to. Sometimes I wear skirts, somtimes I wear jeans, sometimes I don't wear any jewellery or makeup. I don't even feel like I have to make myself look 'pretty' with makeup and heels for my boyfriend, he should like me either way, but I'll do it if I want to.
I don't believe my boyfriend treats me like a little girl, but I know it happens. Sure most of the time I pay for everything when I go out with him, but that's mainly cause he's a broke college student. Usually we'd both pay.
I've had bad experiences with men like who you're talking about, but there are actually good ones, and now I hate men a bit less. Perhaps gender equality is better in some countries than other, and I think it's better here. Or maybe that's just for my generation.
jeez! this was awesome... you kinda make me feel real guilty.. gr8 work! when's the follow up comin' up?!
I consider myself a progressive thinker and believe in gender equality. I'm a straight male in my twenties and I'll offer my humble opinion...
"I'd noticed that I was constantly seeking this validation from men. I felt good about myself when they were interested in me, but horrendously unattractive when they weren't."
That isn't a case of sexism. EVERYONE, male and female, feels better when other like them and are attracted to them. It's only human to want to be liked, and it's totally up to you to be comfortable with yourself, not up to the opposite sex. What's so wrong about wanting to look good?
"When I look back on our little fling, I become infuriated at how he successfully turned me into the thing I swore I would avoid being."
HE didn't turn you into anything. You ALLOWED YOURSELF to become "the clueless, clingy girl" by not assertively communicating to show your dissatisfaction at his lack of respect for your views on gender equality and your definition of the relationship.
"it pisses me off to no end to think that he probably views me as such"
You, AGAIN, are allowing HIM to undermine your feelings of self-worth.
"I can no longer tolerate the fucked up protector role that so many men assume in relationships."
Your opinion on the "protector role" of males is just that--OPINION--and not all girls would be happy in a relationship without the man filling such a role. It's up to women to assert themselves and not be subjugated by men, but it should also be up to them to form whatever kind of relationship they want--even if they want the man to be dominant.
You're right that sexism is still prevalent on the job and in pop culture. But you're wrong to solely blame men for sexist society. You paint men as a monolithic enemy of women when we're not. You label traditional relationships as intrinsically "fucked up" when some would choose such relationships willingly--and it's their prerogative to live as they see fit.
And you should live your life as you see fit. To strive toward your personal feminist ideal while the females around you live what you believe are demeaning lives is not easy. But hating "men" to get out your frustrations is wrong. Scapegoating men is a demonstration of your own feelings of inadequacy. It's a crutch, and hate and prejudice are bad for your health.
Oops, I forgot: I just wanted to give commendations for a wonderfully readable blog post. It really wasn't too long. You said what had to be said. I look forward to more in the future and wish you all the best!
Please don't pay attention to bunkerstatements. As another 20-something straight male I will attest to the difficulty of curing our ignorance to the patriarchal society we live in and perpetuate. I appreciate you putting yourself out there to help us understand what it is like to be a women in this society. Best of luck to you.
first of all english is not my basic language so i'll surely make some spelling mistakes. It seems very strange that one guy can transform you that much, there must be some other reasons for your hate. I agree with bunkerstatements, and i think that if you are feeling powerless, start kicking some serious ass, or you will be a puppet all of your life. But don't hate, because that feeling clouds the thinking proces and it won't set you free. You will still be dependent on the object of hate, it's a perpetual cicle (like in a fucked up marriage). I believe that you should continue what you are doing but in the same time i know that you don't need confirmation from anyone (and especially not from a guy, like me). That is the first step to wisdom. tha tha
I attend a major state university in the South and I can identify with so much of what you wrote. Your description of your relationship is disturbingly similar to my last two romantic endeavors. My intentions to appear casual and independent inevitably end up with me not speaking up for my true intentions in the relationship soon enough or getting walked all over because he knows I'll shut out other men even if we don't make it official. Especially coming from an area that still prides itself on producing Southern Belles, I find it difficult to balance my fury with the status quo of gender inequality and my desire not to seem like an upity, man-hating bitch (which is what you get called when you speak out about it a little too often around here). I struggle in relationships because a part of me still wants to be taken care of and swept off of my feet even though I know and I project the knowledge that this practice is bad for women in general. Also, because the male practice of doting on women in whom they're interested has become so ingrained in our culture, I have a hard time determining whether my male friends are "into me" if they don't behave in a chivelrous manner (even though I know that they know I'd rather have a relationship not based on behavior like that). This last little bit is probably more of a confidence issue, but I can't help but second guess everything and take hits hard when I've been told that I'm too "Strong a woman to ever make a good wife".
I, as a woman, used to fuck like a man. Then, one man, one man I was intensely attached to and in love with, one man that I meant to spend the rest of my life with, criticized my past experiences. It's been saddening to see how much this has affected me. I'd like to think that gender politics don't effect me, but they do.
And here I grew up in a feminist home. But not even feminist in the traditional sense. Only that my single mother raising two kids put herself through engineering school and didn't think twice about it. I think that's what it comes down to. Men don't have to think twice about life plans or sex. Women seem to. If they don't, they're rash, irrational sluts.
I love this world.
The first thing I'd like to say is that I liked your article. It looked like you were trying to keep a complicated story simple. The part of it that you showed us seemed very personal, rather than academic, and I appreciate the guts it took to do that. Thanks. I've had some similar experiences with struggling to not appear needy, but still stand up for myself. The worst for me was when I got close and then they thought that they needed to "be there for me" with every little thing because I couldn't do it myself, then criticize me for being overly dependent, when really they just invited themselves anyway! ... Sorry... It's something we all get mad about because people are all raised with these expectations for one person to be passive and the other to take advantage of their passivity, to be aggressive. Even when a person isn't really so passive, or so aggressive, they can get displaced into those roles anyway. I think the solution might start with pointing out some of these roles we play, and making new ones to replace them with. I haven't tried it yet, but I figure it's worth a shot. Bringing it up on a date is gonna be the hard part :)
There was one other thing that I wanted to say:
Bunkerstatements_ is totally clueless.
What he missed was that this story (at least how I understood it too be) was not an attack on men, or a dissertation on gender politics.
It was about a persons feelings, and an illustration of the change in her emotional perspective of her place in life from kindergarten to adulthood.
I hope that any men reading this will pay closer attention to this aspect, and acknowledge it, when it is so obviously present, before critiquing. It is very disrespectful to do otherwise.
I'd say we have made some progress...but only what society will allow us to make. I can't lie, I do like it when a man pays...but that is me letting him think he's the man, where I realize I've just gotten a free meal :) It is most definately hard to get a job in an evironment that is mostly ruled by men, and seems the woman has to 'prove' herself first, whereas men are MEN and don't have to subject to this. I'd say we're getting there...it will take time!
I (a man) prefer to have dates average out to be 50/50 splits and encourage all women I know to be as independent as possible. I'm also big into letting men/women play whatever sports they want to (which is a big problem at my old high school).
I must say however that there are some things that make working with women hard. Like how they always seem to be talking about another one, or noticing someone else giving them a dirty look from the other side of the street!
However, women at my job tend to work harder than the men. And yea... They also catch on faster. Only thing you can't seem to get a woman to do is take out the trash. That of course always seems to be the guy's job... lol
Anyways I found this post through stumbleupon. No idea how old it is but I wanna throw out my support to you :p
Post a Comment